top of page

Click To Open The Spotify Playlist

Week 33:

Olivia Rodrigo

traitor

Artist Introduction

Olivia Rodrigo is this generation's pop rock princess. She has won 3 Grammys and just released her 3rd studio album. Now she is known for her music but she started off as a child actor on Disney Channel! Full disclosure: these 9 songs mostly showcase her lyric writing abilities and not necessarily her pop rock side (aside from good 4 u). Her writing style feels like you are reading her diary entries about love, heartbreak, and life. As a 33 year old teenager, I really connect to the nostalgic sound and deep lyrics. So get your tissues, a pint of ice cream, and get ready to reminisce about your past breakups!

Katerina Cascella

Most Popular

drivers license
Katerina Cascella

her break out single! I would be surprised if you didn't already know this song. It made it so big that SNL made a skit about it. For some reason, even though the song is about the heartbreak of a 17 year old anyone can connect to the raw emotion Olivia is portraying in the song.

good 4 u

From Disney Star to pop rock princess. A lot of people think this song sounds like Misery Business by Paramour but I don't hear that. (A previous member of Paramour tried getting writing credit for this song but he didn't get it). But it does have the same feel as pop rock from the 2000s which is why my elder millennial heart loves it so much.

traitor

When this album came out I played it and this song on repeat. So much so that Vin asked me if I was upset with him.

Personal Favorites

the grudge

a lot of people, me included, believe this song is about Taylor Swift. I applaud Olivia for going toe to toe with the lyricist of my generation and solidifying her slot of the next great lyricist for her generation and teenagers in their 30s everywhere.

stupid song

off her new album! I like the combo of the good lyrics and fun music.

begged

it's the lyrics for me in this one that I love so much. Being able to put into words the feeling of not being good enough and constantly feeling like you need to ask for love and attention in a relationship but at the same time believing that you should be grateful for what you are getting. It's such a heartbreaking song but so beautifully written and song. Especially the background locals feeling so soft and strong at the same time.

Unique Songs

girl i've always been

obviously a huge shift from her normal pop rock/heartbreak ballads. Very folky and country which is so much fun coming from her. I was hoping her 3rd album would be more folky and country because of this one song

expectations

I love a good 80s inspired synth song! I already know I'm losing Dad with this one lol. Who can't connect with going to a bar in a mini dress with a vodka cran in one hand and a purse in the other!? I think this might be the wrong audience...

All I Want- From "High School Musical, The Show: The Musical"

so this song is not off any of her albums but instead from her Disney Days on the show "High School Musical: The Musical: The Series." So lyrically still very similar to her stuff now but more musical-esque. Hence being from "High school musical the musical the series" she also wrote and performed this song when she was 16 years old! So much talent at such a young age!!

Conclusions

Cascella Family Reviews

Vin Cascella

O-Rod! First thing’s first, being married to a thirty-something year old teenager, we listen to a lot of Olivia Rodrigo. I’m very well versed in her catalogue and although I do enjoy her music quite a lot, I would have gone in a bit of a different direction in the song choices. Nonetheless, lets see how this goes!


drivers license: Rightfully her biggest song, the lead single off of her debut album Sour, this song pretty much encapsulates the Olivia Rodrigo experience. Teenage heartbreak wrapped up into a pop ballad with a little bit of an edge. I think a part that helps make her so universally liked is that her songs are relatable or at least nostalgic to a wide audience. Highschool dramas were half a life ago for me but doesn’t mean I haven’t forgotten about all the dramatic music I used to listen to back in the day… still listen to today.


good 4 u: Everyone always compares this song to Misery Business by Paramore and of course I see the semblance but I always thought this music sounded like early 2000s Kelly Clarkson. Pop rock anthem with a killer voice. I’ve always had one problem with this song, I really dislike the sound mixing on this song, every instrument is muddy. I know in the end it’s a pop song where the vocals are most important but I wish all of the instruments had a bit more of an edge. Either way this song is a modern bop and unfortunately is the only “rocker” on this entire selection so I’ll enjoy this song while I can.


traitor: For the record I like deja vu better but this song is solid too. Strap in everyone, we’re in for a journey. Get ready to house a pint of Ben and Jerry’s while you cry into a pillow, or whatever teenage girls do during heartbreak. Dye your hair blue? Like drivers license, its teenage angst and heartbreak distilled into three and a half minutes.


the grudge: I’d say things are going to change but that would be a lie, we’re in deep on the girl pop depression lyrics. This is supposed to be a compliment but I’m not clever enough with words to properly explain what I mean. O-Rod’s lyrical content is for heartbroken teenage girls  as “Live Laugh Love” signs are for middle aged housewives in the early 2000s. Essential. I’ve listened to this entire playlist a lot over the last few years so to mix it up I listened to a full live version. She really does have a stellar voice. Whether the music is for you or not, I think it’s fair to say that she is insanely talented.


stupid song: New O-rod, only a couple months old! First minute is the same as the last few songs but then it kicks in for the second half with some prominent drums and a little guitar towards the end. The second half of this song reminds me of FLORIDA! By Taylor Swift, just a thing. Happier lyrics which is a nice change of pace. I don’t know much about music but she does this thing in a lot of her songs (a few in the selection) where it sounds like she is singing up and down a scale. I’m sure it’s something I just don’t know what it is, sounds good. That’s all.


begged: Quick note. The album title “you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love” is excellent and very apt. More of the same here, she has a monster voice and her lyrics are brutal. I’m sure there is an entire generation using this music as their breakup soundtrack. And after they listen they can check out Heart Meets Mind Psychology group!


girl i’ve always been: It’s definitely different. Little country/folk pop. It’s not for me but it’s refreshing to hear something different. I think she does a good job with it, just not for me. Points for being unique.


expectations: More girly synth pop. I can feel Dad Cascella’s score plummeting as we speak!  I mean sure. Between “girl i’ve always” been and “expectations” I would’ve went for a bunch of different other songs to fit into the unique character but I’m not the one choosing this week. What’s Wrong With Me ft. Robert Smith (dude is all over the place recently) would’ve been a cool song off of the same album. All American Bitch would’ve been a rocker to break up the ballads. But here we are, girl power pop! If they do a Sex In The City reboot, this song will be featured.


All I Want- From “High School Musical”: This is actually a hilarious final selection.  From the hit television series “High School Musical: The Musical: The Series” (that’s seriously the title!) Olivia would’ve been around 16 years old when this came out which is absolutely wild. Another sad ballad to wrap up the selection. This time with a couple extra instruments, it kind of sounds like a low budget broadway production, which checks out. Not really going to acknowledge the music in this one since it’s a Disney track but she sounds great once again.


Olivia Rodrigo, at only 23 years old, wow that’s wild, is one of the biggest acts in all of music. All three of her studio albums have hit number 1 on the Billboard charts and literally EVERY song off her most recent album charted in not just the top 100 but in the top 30! That’s insane. Despite the 9 songs on display this week I would characterize O-rod as a pop rock artist. Taking inspiration from many of the same artists I grew up listening to, I think she is one of the best pop artists out there right now. I didn’t know where to fit this story into my review but one of my favorite recent stories from O-rod is about how her own mom skipped her set at Lollapalooza to go see Korn. She mentions how there probably isn’t much overlap between those fandoms but I have seen Korn before in concert and I would love to see O-rod!

7.7

Dad Cascella

Ok Mrs guest selector, you’ve given us pop princess Olivia Rodrigo.  As being a rocker, pop is definitely not my greatest listening pleasure.  But as I’ve explained in the past, if you’re good musically/lyrically, then I’m in (i.e. Michael Jackson).  All I know about Miss Rodrigo is that she’s young and she comes from a Disney background.  I’ve only watched her once when about 6 months ago I watched her Tiny Desk, which I thought was pretty good.  Let’s see what this girl’s got.


DRIVERS LICENSE-  soft, almost whispering singing with piano accompanying.  Beautiful soft ballad of heartbreak with heartfelt, and fairly clever lyrics.  I liked her singing, but at the 2:30 mark, with the bridge beginning “Red lights, stop signs”, it thought why go there.  I didn’t like this part, it changed the dynamic of the song.  Btw, as the songs beginning built up, it reminded me a little of a Paramore song (Hate To See Your Heart Break).  Good opening song, hurt a bit by bridge.


GOOD 4 U-   classic pop-sounding song with moments of Rock and Roll.  Not crazy about her singing in this one, though I liked at the 2:00 minute mark she let us hear, shortly, her punkish side.  Song about an ex-boyfriend with tougher lyrics, but not as harsh as Alannis M.  After these first two songs I looked up when Olivia wrote these (age 20).  A bit of angst I sense.  Hope all of the selections don’t follow suit.


TRAITOR-  Another very soft ballad accompanied with synth keyboard and guitar.  Sorry, but three songs in a row of heartbreak, angst, and a no good boy.  While the lyrics are good and tell a story, it’s getting tired Olivia.  You’re cute, personable, and obviously very talented.  Get over it.  Musically this was fine, and again, her singing also fine.


THE GRUDGE-  Yup, again whispered-type singing with slow piano chords.  Builds up into another emotional heartbreak and tale of unforgiveness.  Musically, very similar to DRIVERS LICENSE.  Overall, same old, same old.  Does this girl only know heartbreak or does she have any other life experiences.


STUPID SONG-  slow piano into a faster song.  A little bit different sound than previous selections, but not much.  Her fast lyrics are delivered pretty cool.  I’m guessing this is a love song before being dumped and her realizing that the guy is an idiot?  I like the music better.  The song is fine.


BEGGED-  Nice guitar work, and then echo’d singing to another melancholy song.  Lyrically, meh, nothing too new, but her singing is nice again.  “I’m trapped within my life”.  Really??  Such a hard life??  C’mon, find your strength and write about that!!  Again, nothing too deep here other than her angst.  I’m really, really hoping that the unique/different section of songs are just that.


GIRL I’VE ALWAYS BEEN-  Ok, this is different.  I like the sound of this quick ditty.  Sounds like she’s actually having fun with this one, which may have been recorded live in studio.  Very clever lyrics, but I’m confused.  Is she trying to figure out if she’s the reason for past romantic break-ups?  Ok song.


EXPECTATIONS-  Now this is a different beginning, almost DEVO’ish, with sythesizing and electronica.  Wasn’t crazy about her bubblegum style singing (she’s better than that).  Funny, I think the song is pretty bad, but in these lyrics she’s finally showing a little backbone. “I’m not giving my heart with zero stipulations, now I take careful consideration” and “past mistakes are just just new information, these days I’ve got expectations”.  About effing time.


ALL I WANT-  opening sounded a bit like Lennon’s “Imagine” on piano, which then led to a very sweet, strong song.  And the music adding strings added to the song greatly.  And I thought with her singing inflections, it was some of her best singing.  Very good lyrics.  Pretty damn impressive as I believe this song came out when she was very young (16?).  While the content of the lyrics are similar, they’re beautifully delivered.  And I found myself rooting for her on this track.  The song actually reminded me of Christina A. song “Beautiful”.  Damn, it’s fromHigh School Musical but I admit, it was my favorite of these selections.


So that’s it for Olivia Rodrigo.  I have to say, I was somewhat disappointed.  Here’s a young girl, who undoubtedly can sing.  Her soprano singing is different in today’s market of pop stars.  She plays piano and guitar, and watching her on some live performances, she very good at both.  But I found these selections to be mostly one-dimensional, with not much difference in sound or lyric content.  As she is young, I hope she branches out and changes things up a bit.  Show us some different chops, I bet she can do it.  I was very, very impressed with her philanthropic works, way too numerous to mention all, but one, Spicy Pisces T-shirts, with all proceeds going to young girls educations is extremely impressive.  Sorry Olivia, but I give you a 6.2

Your Rating:

0.0

Average Rating:

0 votes

Join The Discussion!

Connect With Us

Join Our Music Community Today

This Spot will be for an address if we ever make one. For now. Hi!

  • Instagram
  • Discord
  • Spotify
  • Youtube

Email Address Placeholder

Phone Number Placeholder

The Cascella Music Club

 

© 2026 by The Cascella Music Club

 

bottom of page